MCLemuelG

You know I'm going to retract my earlier statements. I reread it again, and I love the ending now. It's dissatisfying and disappointing, but it

s real. Sometimes reality sucks, but the truth doesn't need to be comforting, and often isn't.

I find it hilarious that people get so offended when you point out that Harry Potter has mediocre writing and a recycled plot, because I always found that those were two of the greatest qualities to HP. Don't get me wrong, I love a more sophisticated read, but sometimes a more laid back relaxed read is nice. And of course the plot is recycled, most plots are. The reason it's recycled is cuz it works.

Of course it would be controversial, but all the best art is controversial. I think it would remind people of a lot of terrible things in the world, and make them think about them critically.

Yeah it would!

On the nerdcore side of things I'm a huge MC Frontalot fan and I also love some more traditional hip hop artists like Eminem 2pac and Jay-Z.