Anime avenue, Google that good thing. It's pretty good about updating new stuff and isn't full of cluttery ads and videos if you don't use adblock.
And as for magic/action anime, right now Magi is in its second season and season 1 was a two cor. I shotgunned season one and burned myself out, but I'll probably watch 2 when it's done. Noragami is premering now and is fucking awesome. Wolf and Krys should look into that one.
Also, Catgirl! kinda
Seth likes Fairytale, he's around here somewhere. I've never watched it, but I have a friend who loves it, so go ahead. Plus, the boobies on that show are humungloidous.
Everyone has been loosing their mind over Attack on Titan, to the point that it had a panle at an anime convention I went to not long ago. I didn't recognize any of the costumes, since I refuse to watch.
I know you said you didn't like drama, but look into Mikakunin de Shinkoukei. Mashiro is the cutest little girl of all time ever, ever. She makes Shirly Temple look like a cancerous lump of nut meat. Without spoliers, Wolf and Krys, you would like it. It's down your alley.
Also, don't apologize for spamming the forum, even if Spleen yells at you and threatens spankings.